Case Studies Club
Business Strategy School
Case Success Guide
The Arsenal Paradox - Fiduciary Duty in an Age of Conflict
Meridian Capital Must Confront the Ethical Dilemma of Maximizing Returns in the Defense Sector While Upholding Fiduciary Duty
Meridian Capital, an asset management firm known for its aggressive, opportunistic investment strategy, faces a dilemma as a highly profitable opportunity in defense technology conflicts with the ethical concerns of its institutional clients. The firm must choose between maximizing investor returns by embracing the defense sector or aligning with growing demands for ethical investing, a decision that will redefine its identity and future.
Core Themes:
Business Case Analysis
Turn Business Challenges Into Strategic Wins
Discover how our proven case analysis process can work for you
Read our Success GuideOverview
A mid-sized asset management firm, built on a reputation for aggressive, sector-agnostic opportunism, stands at a crossroads. A generational investment opportunity has emerged within the defense technology sector, promising returns that could significantly outperform market benchmarks and secure the firm's competitive standing for the foreseeable future. The numbers are clean, the logic undeniable. Yet, the same geopolitical instability fueling this boom presents a significant ethical and reputational challenge.
The central dilemma is not one of legality, but of principle and long-term strategy. The firm's mandate is unequivocal: maximize investor returns. However, a substantial portion of its capital under management comes from institutions, such as university endowments, that are increasingly sensitive to the ethical implications of their investments. This analysis will dissect the situation, weigh the strategic options, and recommend a course of action that navigates the treacherous territory between pure profit maximization and the growing demand for corporate conscience. The decision will set a precedent, defining the firm's character in an era where capital is no longer silent.
Backstory
Meridian Capital has cultivated an identity as a shrewd and unsentimental player in the asset management space. With $2.3 billion in assets under management (AUM), the firm has consistently delivered superior returns by adhering to a simple, powerful philosophy: capital flows to opportunity, regardless of its source. The firm’s "opportunistic approach" is not merely a marketing slogan; it is the core of an operational model that has attracted a diverse investor base seeking raw performance, unburdened by ethical or social constraints. This approach has proven highly successful, solidifying the firm's reputation and fueling its growth.
The current challenge arises from an unprecedented confluence of factors in the defense technology sector. Heigh...
🔓 Unlock This Case Study
Access full cases, analysis, recommendations, and community insights
